4points · 1d ago

Ask HN: OpenAI Astra post-launch slump?

Anyone frustrated with GPT-6 Astra lately? The quality swings wildly from session to session. It feels like the backend is silently redirecting to Luna or other models. I wasn't aware OpenAI did this, but now it makes so much sense because some of the answers and performance read very much like a different model.

Lately it misses obvious details in the code, only to say "oh yeah, I should have mentioned that!"

I explicitly tell it to look at the code in the context, then I start to realize it's making generalizations. "oh yeah, I should have answered from the code!"

The frustrating aspect is that the items listed above are like models from 6-12 months ago. Astra is absolutely amazing and shouldn't perform this way.

news.ycombinator.com·by iJohnDoe·1d ago

Discussion 6 comments

bestnew
⌘↵ to post · markdown supported
mattm·1d ago
After using Claude extensively for about 9 months, last month I let my subscription lapse and tried out OpenAI instead. It was fine to start but then I noticed quality issues and just needing more rework time than I was accustomed to with Claude. This month I switched back to Claude. I will say it's much better at writing code comments than Claude - I can't stand the way Claude writes comments.
0
muzani·20h ago
Astra is terrible with thinking. Sol 6.1 is better for anything that requires thought. The usual process is to write up what you want (the AI can interview you) and then give the doc to Astra to work on.

Astra is an implementation model. Use it with instructions like "implement this PRD" or "do that ticket" or "integrate Stripe into this app".

Opus 5.5 does both well so Astra now feels a little worse, but Astra Light has been very capable of completing the job, from what I've experienced in the past few weeks.

0
booty·1d ago
For budgetary reasons Astra is probably less than 10% of my LLM usage, but I have not noticed those swings. Just used it to review a bunch of architecture. Very strong performer.

One of the hallmarks of Luna is that it's slow. Also, while Luna's price/performance is outstanding (astounding, even) ...it's also sort of dumb. Astra isn't perfect but it's been consistently miles above Luna for me.

I believe you, though. Like many/most in this space, I suspect they mess with this stuff all the time behind the scenes. And they're not necessarily serving you the same thing they're serving me.

0
kingkongjaffa·1d ago
Why are the OP and /booty talking about Luna?

Sol is the next biggest model and pretty good, Luna isn't even in the conversation?

0
reddmachine·1d ago
Quite honestly 6-Astra has disappointed ever since Opus 5.5. It makes assumptions without clarification, burns through weekly quotas and just feels slower and more clunky. 6.1-Sol seems to have the right balance of quality for price/usage.

I start everything with an Opus 5.5 first step and maybe have 6-Astra review on High effort.

0